东亚历史演进图 [美国媒体]

The History of East Asia: Every Year

东亚历史演进图



视频简介：全程展现整个中国、蒙古、契丹、朝鲜和日本从商朝至现代的过程。感谢观看，、订阅、链接和分享！

KnownNiche2
Japan was eating popcorg the whole time?

日本全程在吃爆米花。

BlazingMagpie2
+TheLegoCreator12344 More like they can't get out of their island.?

不如说是他们没法走出他们的岛。

xenotypos2
Not the whole time, in the 1590s just after the Sengoku Jidai they did invade Korea, temporarily though. An interesting war, lands forces vs navy. Surprisingly, Japan was the land forces (because all armies were initially meant to fight internally during the Sengoku Jidai), a whole lot different from what happened after the Meiji period/westernization.?

不全是如此，16世纪90年代刚过日本战国时代不久，他们就入侵了朝鲜，尽管是暂时的。
这是一场有趣的战争，地面武装vs海军。
令人吃惊的是，日本当时是地面武装（毕竟战国时代所有军队最初都是内战），这与之后的明治时期/西方化所发生的战斗完全不同。

村正本刀に三世2
so was taiwan?

日本吃爆米花，台湾也没什么区别。

YummYakitori1
+xenotypos Japan invaded Korea in 1592, during what was known as the Imjin War (壬辰倭乱 / ????). They besieged the capital of Pyongyang and almost managed to occupy the entire Korean peninsula within several months. This shows that Japan already had aggressive, expansionist intentions towards mainland Asia by the 1600s; and this also shows that by the time of the Imjin War, Japan's military capability did not lose out to that of Korea's, but was still a far cry from that of China's; since China had already invented gunpowder & hand cannons by the Ming Dynasty. Since Korea was at the time a tributary state of Ming Dynasty China, troops were deployed and sent over to help defend Korea in the war against Japan.?

+xenotypos 日本入侵朝鲜是在1592年，也即众所周知的壬辰倭乱期间。
他们只花了数个月就包围了平壤并几乎占领了整个朝鲜半岛。这展示了日本在17世纪已经有了向亚洲大陆侵略、扩张的意图；也同样展示了朝鲜之役，日本并没有输掉战争，但仍然跟中国不可同日而语。
那时的中国明朝已经发明了火枪/手铳。
自从朝鲜成为明朝的附属国以来，在战争中军队就被分配并派驻保卫朝鲜来对抗日本。

xenotypos1
+YummYakitori Cannons were a problem, but handcannons were just a primitive version of the arquebus, which Japan used with perfection (second only to Europeans). No, Japan had two problems to invade China: 1. It was a fucking big empire, trying to conquer a land with so many people was madness unless they had a clear technological superiority (which wasn't the case) 2.They didn't have cannons since all their army was meant to fight on land. Their soldiers had only fought the civil war for more than a century, they had no idea how to fight on the sea. And the reason they invaded is kinda obvious: for garantying Japan to remain at peace. I don't think the higher ups thought seriously they could invade China, but they had to do something about the awful lot of armed soldiers that had suddenly nothing to do in Japan since the Sengoku Jidai ended. Well, they sent them fight a meaningless war to make them busy. If it worked, good, if it failed, they got rid of a problem too.?

+YummYakitori 大炮是个问题。但手铳当时不过是火绳钩枪的最初版本，这种枪日本当时用得最好（仅次于欧洲人）。
不过，日本入侵中国有两个问题：1.这是一个如此庞大的帝国，除非拥有明确的科技优势否则占领人口众多的土地是疯狂的。2.他们所有部队都是陆上作战没有大炮。他们的士兵们内战超过了1个世纪，他们不知道如何海上作战。
另外他们入侵的动机是相当明显的：为了保证日本的和平。
我不认为点赞很多的、认为日本可以入侵中国的想法是严肃的，但面对壬辰倭乱结束后突然无事可做的、国内庞大的武装士兵，日本人必须得做点什么。然后，他们就派他们为没什么意义的战争忙碌。如果这成功了，很好，如果失败了，他们也摆脱了麻烦。

YummYakitori1
+xenotypos Precisely my point too, that China had a great advantage over Japan until its' rapid decline following Manchu rule during the Qing Dynasty which lasted from 1644 to 1911, allowing Japan & the rest of the world to catch up / surpass their level of technology. Gunpowder was first discovered in China during the Song Dynasty (宋朝), and from then on, it has spread to the Middle East, Japan & Europe. Ironically, one of China's greatest inventions eventually came back to haunt them during the Qing Dynasty and the Republican era, when European colonial powers began waging the Opium Wars and began colonising parts of China such as Macau (by the Portuguese Empire) and Hong Kong (by the British Empire). Of course, then there was Japan who ate up the whole of Manchuria & Taiwan before edging their way into the rest of the Chinese mainland.?

+xenotypo 你我观点正好一样。
当时中国面对日本拥有压倒性优势，直到随后的满族在1644-1911年清朝期间统治中国。这给了日本和世界其他地方以时间来追赶/超越中国人的科技水平。
火枪是中国在宋朝首先发明的，至那时起，火枪技术传播到了中东、日本和欧洲。讽刺的是，一个中国最伟大的发明，最终在清朝和民国以伤害他们的方式还了回来，当时欧洲殖民力量开始发动鸦片战争，并殖民了中国的澳门（葡萄牙帝国）和香港（大英帝国）。
当然了，之后日本又吞并了整个满洲和台湾，并缓慢侵吞余下的中国大陆。

YummYakitori1
If not for the discovery of gunpowder which then led to the widespread use of it, perhaps the Europeans would never had been able to become the dominant global power; and neither would Japan have the military capability & technology to invade so many other East / Southeast Asian countries following the rapid industrialisation of the Meiji Era (明治时代).?

要是火枪没有发明出来，导致其广泛传播使用，也许欧洲人跟本就不会成为全球统治力量；
而日本也绝不会由于明治时代的迅速工业化，而拥有军队力量/科技来入侵大片东亚/东南亚国家。

xenotypos1
+YummYakitori With "if" we can reshape the world as it pleases us. So perhaps yes, perhaps not. Actually, Europeans had the lead in many fields such as sciences, architecture, standards of living etc... from the 16th century on, BUT, not that much militarily (except for the navy). Take the Ottoman empire: they had the same technology as Europe (quickly adopted the arquebus, as China did too), and had a huge military golden age during the 16th/17th centuries. Yet, they still lost ground afterwards, little by little, compared with European powers. Why? Because Europe's rise wasn't due to some military technologies but due to the entire society working a certain way toward "progress". Since Guttenberg (and many other events such as the reconquista and the fall of Contantinople (which led many scholar to flee towards Italy)), knowledge in Europe spread exponentionally. The number of books printed compared with before was just crazy. I believe that's what made the real difference. It's a unending dynamic that lead to continious improvments for example in weapons. The Japanese probably understood that and didn't just adopt western weaponry: they changed their entire society to make it works the same way as for western countries, in every aspect of their life. And a miracle happened. As Japan also took long ago from China when the Chinese culture was very influencal, they successfully took from Europe. It wasn't easy though. Nowadays, every country is like that so it's not really something special anymore, but the context back then was different. Anyway, I admit Europe was helped by numerous factors compared with China: Arabo-Indian numbers, the ancient Greek's incredible science/philosophy which would be too long to enumerate, an effective alphabet herited from the latin one... also being divided in several little and highly competitive states (instead of a lazy big one) probably helped. But I think gunpowder is just one of those things, not at all the most important.?

+YummYakitori 所谓的“如果/要是”之类，我们可以重塑这个世界来愉悦自己。所以也许是，也许不是，事实上，欧洲人在诸如科学、建筑、生活标准等方面在16世纪已经领先，唯独军事力量不够（海军除外）。
说到奥斯曼帝国：他们拥有跟欧洲一样的科技（与中国一样迅速采纳了火枪），在16-17世纪拥有巨大的军事黄金时代。
然而，相比于欧洲力量，他们随后依然丧失了土地，一点又一点。为何？
因为欧洲崛起不是因为拥有一些军事科技，而是由于整个社会走在了“进步”这个明确的道路上。自从古藤堡以及众多其他事件如收复失地运动和君士坦丁堡的陷落（导致大量学者逃往意大利），知识在欧洲指数级传播。大量书籍相比之前疯狂复印。我相信这才是欧洲真正的不同之处。这种无持续的动态影像导致了持续进步包括武器。
日本人可能知道这点所以才不单单只采纳了西式武器：他们对整个社会进行了改变、他们生活的各个层面，让它像西方国家那样运转。奇迹发生了。在中国文化拥有巨大影响力之时，日本人也花了很长时间来学习中国，让他们学习欧洲，尽管这也不容易但成功了。
无论如何，我同意，相比于中国欧洲得到了大量因素的助益：阿拉伯数字、古希腊难以置信的科技/哲学，不胜枚举，从拉丁文继承而来的有效的字母……也包括分裂为数个小而高度竞争的国家（而非大二慵懒的国家），这点可能也有作用。
我认为火枪不过是其中一个因素，同时也不是所有因素中最重要的。

hiiamso shook1
poor korea :( always invaded by their neighbors and neighbors' neighbors.?

可怜的朝鲜，总是被他的邻居入侵，邻居、各种邻居。

Mega Trunks4 个
hi im so shocked they even invaded by themselves (Kim Jong nuke boi)?

我对他们甚至自我内战感到震惊（北朝鲜和韩国）。

??3 个
White Jesus I'm korean(of course south). president Moon is sending money to N.K. even now. and North korea using it to develop nuke. In addition, the president said "I had feel the joy of the victory of communist when Vietnam war." so I think Moon is communist. But many people like President Moon because just his face. I don't know why does Moon is president. I want you to know something like this. I am not good at English. I'm sorry.?

我就是韩国人。
我们的总统正在向朝鲜撒钱，而朝鲜把它们拿来发展核力量。
而且，总统还说了“在越战期间，我觉得GCD的胜利就是个玩笑。”
所以我认为我们的总统是GCD。但许多人喜欢他就因为他的那张脸。我不知道为何他能成为总统。我只希望你们能知晓这些事情。我英语不好，抱歉。

????2 个
?? fuck you?

?? CNM

Numu Numu1 个
Koea is the Poland of Asia?

朝鲜就是亚洲的波兰。

Quick Lemon7 个
Who else watched only China??

这视频除了中国外，你还能看见啥？

Collective Toothbrush4周前
Quick Lemon I think most would only watch China. Korea and Japan didn't have much border changes haha?

Quick Lemon我觉得大多数人都只会看到中国。朝鲜和日本的边境变化并不大。哈哈哈

Henk Waterlander2
I can see why China calls itself 'The Middle Kingdom'.?

我知道为何中国称自己为“中央（Middle）王国”了。

Hyltonial I2
Henk Waterlander Because we were surrounded by barbarians & nomads?

+Henk Waterlander 毕竟我们被蛮族和游牧民包围着。

Dark PePe2
+yuenhang fung Mistranslation, more like Central Kingdom.?

这是误译，准确的说法是“中央（Central）王国”。

AdrianAtGaming1
actually its more like how europeans used to think the earth is the middle of the universe?

事实上，这更像是欧洲人过去所认为的地球是宇宙的中心一样。

jialin chen1
because it comes from the philosophy, not too bold and not too humble. just in the middle.?

因为这来自于哲学，不卑不亢。就是在中央。

Ann Nee1（修改过）
Hylton Li and you were barbarians who surrounded Koreans.?

Hylton Li 而你们是包围在韩国人周围的野蛮人。

Hyltonial I1
+Ann Nee Really? Then why all Korean history were written in Hanja? Why scholars insist king Seijong to continue using Hanja even Hangul was found??

+Ann Nee 噢是吗？那么为何所有朝鲜历史都是用朝鲜汉字写就的？为何在朝鲜文发明之后，学者们依然要求世宗大王坚持使用朝鲜汉字？

Ruickhan Lo1
China actually was kind of cool country. But now in modern day, of course Japan and Europe is faar much better country than China. China kind of sucks now and they would never surpass Japan. So, yeah.. Japan is the coolest country in East Asia.?

中国当时确实非常的拉风。但今天，日本和欧洲当然比中国好太多了。
如今的中国很糟，他们永远都超越不了日本。所以，是的。日本是东亚最拉风的国家哦。

Roger Wang9 个（修改过）
Ruickhan Lo, that's an odd statement, because China has already surpassed Japan on multiple fronts, ecommerce, IT, space technology, military technology, supercomputers, consumer drones, AI. Japan only dominates its traditional industries like cars and consumer electronics and its military hardware are all bought from the US. So China surpassing Japan is already happening, Japan ahead of china is a historical abnormality, and China is simply back to where it should be and had always been for thousands of years, the only leading country in Asia. And when did Japan defeat china? Japan took at most 1/3 of China during WW2, Chinese government managed rest of 2/3, and before Japanese surrender, Chinese/Japanese war was at an impasse, so what defeat are you talking about??

Ruickhan Lo 你的说法真是古怪。毕竟中国已经在大量领域超过的日本，经济、IT、空间技术、军事技术、超级计算机、无人机、AI。
日本只在传统工业如汽车和电子消费品方面占据主导地位，而军事装备还是从美国购买的。
所以中国超越日本已经发生了，日本超过中国是历史畸形，中国不过是回到自己理应在的位置上，这个位置已经持续了数千年了，亚洲唯一的领导国家。
另外日本何时击败过中国？日本在二战期间占领了中国近三分之一，中国zf掌管着余下的三分之二，在日本投降之前，中日战争就陷入了僵局之中，所以你所说的击败中国是什么鬼玩意儿？

太郎龟头3 个
中 means "central", Chinese always believe they are central of the world, they occupied all Asia except India, they even invaded and occupied most land of Europe. But Chinese has a fatal flaws: corruption and proud, a government usually cannot last 200 years.?

中的意思是“中央”，中国人一直相信他们是世界的中央，他们占领了除印度外的整个亚洲，他们甚至入侵并占领了欧洲大量土地。
但中国人也有致命弱点：腐败和自傲，所以一个zf通常维持不了200年。

Ryan lex6 个
Roger Wang lmao india will overpass china in term of gdp and population in few years time. The chinese dream aint last for long. HAHAHAHAAHAH?

Roger Wang 笑死了，印度在GDP和人口上会超越中国，那用不了几年。中国梦持续不了多久了。哈哈哈哈哈

YummYakitori2 个
Ryan lex India? You have designated shitting streets and most people don’t even have a toilet. Rape crimes, violence and an uncontrollable booming population that the government can’t stop. A few years’ time? Wishful thinking.?

Ryan lex 印度？你说的可是那个有指定的便溺街道、绝大多数人都没有厕所的国度？强奸、暴力和不受控制的、zf无能为力的爆炸式人口增长？
要不了几年？痴心妄想。

Simon Kozlovi?2 个
太郎龟头 China never invaded europe. Ever heard of mediterranean sea? It means middle-earth sea and mediterraneum means middle earth, which makes more sense, since it's between Africa, Europe amd Asia.?

太郎龟头 中国从来没有入侵过欧洲。有听过地中海吗？它指的是地球中央的海洋，它位于非洲、欧洲和亚洲之间。

Ajos1896 Tok1（修改过）
大韩民国历史一万年，祖先来自遥远的火星，曾经一度统治了地球，可惜最后被那美克星人打败。（天啦撸，南朝鲜人气炸的样子笑死惹）?

Joandes feng1
lololololol,他们是宇宙帝国。我等地球夷民不可攀比?

flow slow blow glow plow1
不，他们来自宇宙之外的平行世界。?

flow slow blow glow plow1
Republic of Korea has a history of ten thousand years. The ancestors of Korean came from distant mars. They once ruled the earth, but in the end they were defeated by namek.?

（译注：把楼主的言论翻译成了英文。）

San Thiya1
ha ha are you joking?

哈哈，你太搞笑了。

Kin Yuen Wong1（修改过）
记得那天在看一个关于宇宙的视频然后下面有人写大韩民国全图?

George Communist1
Ajos1896 Tok Слава Укра?н?, героям слава!?

Ajos1896 Tok 光荣的荣耀！

Wingbiu Lei1
Ajos1896 Tok don't say hate-speech?

不要发表仇恨言论

33 puravida1
ok. taiwan no.1?

你说得好。所以taiwan no.1

33 puravida1
we'll make joseon empires. west joseon, east joseon, north joseon, and south joseon. what a great idea!!?

我们创建了大韩帝国。西朝鲜、东朝鲜、北朝鲜、南朝鲜，这主意不错！

Satema 2111 个
??? taiwan no.2，korea no.1！korea will rule the earth！?

taiwan no.2，korea no.1！韩国将会统治地球！

tomato amazing11 个
+Satema 21 Korea and Taiwan are Japanese colony. S.Korea equal Taiwan.?

+Satema 21 韩国台湾都是日本殖民地，韩台平等。

Corrupted Archangel2
Like I understand revolts, but China goes all out when it comes to rebellions. They go big or they go home.?

我所理解的叛乱就是，当叛乱发生，中国迎面正刚。他们要么扩大地盘要么回老家。

Brandon Wu2
+Corrupted Archangel The unsuccessful ones are crushed in less than a year and are therefore not recorded?

+Corrupted Archangel 失败的一方迅速消亡，并且不会存在在历史记录当中。

wakaka2waka2
+Corrupted Archangel They call unsuccessful rebellions "unrest". So we don't know all of the details.?

+Corrupted Archangel 中国人称呼叛乱为“动荡不安”。所以我们没法知晓全部细节。

Heaven Bright2
+Corrupted Archangel I would say historically China was just another planet or world in its own, so a rebellion or civil war was essentially a world war.?

+Corrupted Archangel 我觉得中国历史就是他们自己的另一星球或者世界，所以叛乱或者内战本质上就是世界大战。

Zhou Wu1
Heaven Bright It still is, kind of.?

Heaven Bright 一直如此，某种意义上。

Jhas Jhis2周前
It’s because there was always centralized power, when weak, everyone who thinks they are next in line Duke it out to be the next emperor , like me and my gang vs your gang. But at the same time still united. It’s so interesting?

那是因为一直存在着中央集团的政治力量，当它衰落之后，所有人都认为他们只要打一架就是下一任皇帝，就像我和我的团伙vs你们的团伙。
但同时，依然维持着统一。这点非常有意思。

Ameck162
I never realised how long northern Vietnam was part of China.?

我从来没想过北越作为中国的一部分居然有这么长的时间。

Hoang Vu Cong Minh黄武公明2
+ Ameck16 lol!!?

哈哈哈哈

Felix Korlos2
maybe 1000 years？ vietnan is a little china。?

也许有1000年？越南就是小中国。

Hoang Vu Cong Minh黄武公明2
+Kor Felix 111 BC to 938 and 1407 to 1427.I'm Vietnamese. No Vietnam is Viet Nam. My country is not little China. My country is little Vietnam . :)?

+Kor Felix 公元前111年-公元938年，1407-1427年。
我是越南人，越南不是南越。我的国家也不是小中国。我的国家是小越南。

D??ng Minh8 个（修改过）
yes, you can said 1000 years only 1/4 Vietnam history, chinese cultural is tools for Vietnam to enhance , done, Today with 100 million people , Now Vietnam become a rising Mili- Eco country in region, & we have independence view?

没错，你可以声称1000年不过越南历史的四分之一，中国文化是越南用来提高自己的工具。仅此而已。如今越南成了地区迷你的经济国家，并且我们拥有独立的视野。

Shinichi Kudo7 个（修改过）
+Felix Korlos That's joke. Civilisation appeared in Vietnam first ( google Hong Bang dynasty and Xia dynasty )?

+Felix Korlos 这就是笑话。文明首先出现在越南（谷歌Hong Bang dynasty 和 Xia dynasty）。

太守苏定交趾5 个（修改过）
What about north Vietnam between BC179--BC111 ruled by the local Chinese kingdom of Nanyue?? Oh yeah,you guys in Vietnam thinks that its a Vietnamese kingdom which is called 'Nam Viet' and its founder Zhao-tuo is a Vietnamese king.

公元前179-公元前111年这段时间，北越被中国地方王国南越所统治，你们怎么看呀？
哦对，你们越南人认为南越是越南的王国，它被称为南越（Nam Viet）嘛，创立者赵佗也是越南国王。

firestone_ Firestones3 个（修改过）
太守苏定交趾 in Vietnam official history books, the Nanyue dynasty is not Viet's Dynasty, we even don't admit that! What wrong with you? Zhao Tou was invader of civil China empire.?

太守苏定交趾 越南官方历史书中，南越朝不是越南的王朝，我们甚至都没承认它！你到底怎么回事？

Turng ND3 个
in Vietnam official history books: 仁义之举，要在安民， 弔伐之师莫先去暴。 惟，我大越之国， 实为文献之邦。 山川之封域既殊， 南北之风俗亦异。 自赵丁李陈之肇造我国， 与汉唐宋元而各帝一方。 虽强弱时有不同 而豪杰世未常乏。?

越南官方历史书里是这样说的：（见上面文言文）

Nam Trinh1 个
Jeremy Ksor Not many Vietnamese themselves realize how much they behave like China in Laos, Cambodia and some nearby areas: Don't really integrate, monopolize major businesses, occupy most of the important posts, etc.?

Jeremy Ksor 越南在老挝、柬埔寨和依稀邻近区域表现得有多像中国，认识到这点的越南人并不多。

??1
Korea is too small but they survive very well?

韩国非常小，但他们活得很好。

Tim Baws1
Yes as being china and USA vassal?

没错，以作为美国附庸的方式。

Universal1
typical american meathead, Korea is a better country than both despite the size

典型的美国傻瓜。韩国除了尺寸之外，都要比中美好。

（译注：看上下留言，中间有一条是辱骂中国被蒙满殖民的留言，被举报删掉了。）

Lx北1（修改过）
+Genghis Khan No matter how you deny it ，Yuan was Chinese dynasty history ,Yuan was Chinese culture 、Chinese system ，established by Chinese Confucianism Scholar’help,“Yuan”(元）is Chinese lanuage word from 3000 years ago ancient book《易经》 ，“大哉乾元”，Yuan's capital was in China, in that time ,Outer Mongolia only a provice of Yuan named “岭北行省”(Ling bei provice)......in the world ,any serious historians thinks that the Yuan was China, except keyboard-warrior.So speak clearly, at least Yuan haven't any relation with you now“mongolia”country! lol, China never part of you Outer Knalkna .?
+Genghis Khan 无论你如何否认，元朝都是中国的朝代，元朝是中华文化、中华体系、有中国儒家学者帮助建立起来的。
元是也是3000《易经》上的汉字。元首都也在中国境内，那个时候，外蒙古不过是一个叫“岭北行省”的元朝省份。
在这个世界，任何严肃的历史学家都认为它是中国，出来键盘侠。
所以跟你明确说，至少远超跟你现在的“蒙古”国没半点关系！呵呵，中国从来不是外来可汗的一部分。

Universal1
+北 Lx lol angry chinese mad his people conquered by mongols?

哈哈，愤怒的中国人为他们被蒙古征服而疯狂。

Lx北1（修改过）
+Universal Collection WOW, see any ugly fake koreans always changed father ,China Janpan America ,now to suck the shithole area“Outer Mongolia” to be your leader, but the shithole country have nothing except sheep ,Inner Mongolia still part of China , are you jealous？keep on suck others dick ,little pussy ,full of inferiority complex.?

+Universal Collection 哇奥，瞧瞧那些丑陋的伪造的韩国人，他们一直在找爸爸，先是中国、之后日本，然后是美国，现在又开始舔外蒙古的菊花了，但s坑国家除了绵羊外什么都没有，内蒙古一直都是中国的一部分，你嫉妒吗？继续舔别人的吊把，小荡妇，自卑的东西。

FinJproductions2
Never once in the whole history of China was China called China and yet everyone calls it China.?

中国历史上没有一个中国称呼自己为中国，然而每个人都称呼它为中国。

梁圣泽2

So true hahahahaha..?

说的没错，哈哈哈哈。

Sprie Spear2
+Anonymous Gaming China it's only for English name, but in Chinese China means Middle Kingdom, thousand of years Chinese called their home as central kingdom / middle kingdom / central government as common refer for their country, as outsiders they were told them Great Han or Great T'ang or Qing?

+Anonymous Gaming China只是英语名字，但在汉语里中国的意思就是“中央王国”，数千年来，中国人都是这么称呼自己的家为中央王国，作为外来者他们被称为大汉、大唐或大清。

YangSing12
Can you do the entire history of the British isles??

视频作者，你能制作一部不列颠群岛的整个历史的视频吗？

6663 个
YangSing1 British got nothing until the 12th century. It can’t even hold a candle to great China.?

不列颠在12世纪前什么都没有。不能和中国相提并论。

Trung Huynh2（修改过）
Why is Vietnam omitted? It's an East Asian country with Confucian tradition! Also the Han border is inaccurate, it extends much further into Mongolia than the Ming great wall.?
为何这个视频把越南省略了？它是传统儒家圈的东亚国家！
还有，汉朝边境是不准确的，它进一步囊括了蒙古，越过了明朝时期的长城。

ummYakitori1
Vietnam is geographically in Southeast Asia, but culturally very similar to East Asia

越南地理上就是东南亚，只是文化上跟东亚很类似。

Ivan Lau1
It depends. If they say Vietnam is east asian, some Vietnamese will be offended because they don't like to be associated with China. It's tricky. Vietnamese don't use Chu Nom anymore as well (Japan still uses Kanji and Korea still teaches Hanja). So culturally, they are drifting towards southeast asia. But yes you have a good point.?

这是因为，如果他们说越南是东亚国家，一些越南人就会感到冒犯，毕竟他们不想跟中国发生关系。这很棘手，越南不再使用字喃了（而日本依然在使用日式汉字，朝鲜也一直在教授朝鲜汉字）。
所以文化角度，他们自觉不自觉地趋向与东南亚了。
但没错，你也有你的道理。

安东???1
I learned that Vietnam was Southeast Asia. I'm pretty sure this video only shows about East Asia.?

据我所知，越南是东南亚国家。我确信这部视频只是展示东亚历史。

Ivan Lau1
+??? categorically, it's in Southeast Asia. Culturally, it is closer to East Asia. In terms of culture, language, and naming convention (ie identity).?

+??? 分类上，越南是东亚国家。文化上，它跟东亚更紧密。语言、命名等。

EastAsian Pride6 个
last time I asked some vietnamese. They said they are not east asian and they hate east asian people?

我最后一次问过一些越南人。他们说他们不是东亚国家，他们讨厌东亚人。

BenTheBoss1
wait so japan people came from china????

等等，也就是说，日本人来自中国？？