毁灭古代中国的八大红颜祸水（YouTube评论） [美国媒体]

8 BEAUTIFUL Women Who DESTROYED China

毁灭古代中国的八大红颜祸水（YouTube评论）



When you think about falling empires, and wars, you wouldn't believe that an ancient, elegant, and even beautiful woman could start all that, right? Well, surprizingly there were women in ancient China who did just that, and today we give you some examples of them from history.

当你想到衰落的帝国、战争的时候，你无法相信一个优雅甚至是美丽的古代女子可以引发这一切，对吧？但是令人惊讶的是，中国古代就有存在这样的女子，今天我们给你们一些历史上的例子。


Tamago
Chinese Game of Throne

中国版的《权力的游戏》

Indira Poitier
wow. but is it beautiful women or careless men?

哇，但是这要怪美丽的女人还是粗心的男人呢？

Gordan Giovanna
I wish that I was soo beautiful that everyone prize me but not in that way lol

我希望我美得人人都来夸我，但不是以这种方式。哈哈

ダイノサー京
china, wtf with the wine lakes?

我去，中国的“酒池”是搞什么？

zeiitgeist
useless things to display wealth.

炫耀财富的无用之物呗。

dnguyen253
If I had money and power I would like to swim in a pool of wine too.

如果我有钱有权，我也会想要在灌满美酒的池子里游泳的。

ayanada06
Did some of these women actually destroy these ancient dynasties or did the ruling men in question just have really poor judgement and sketchy priorities?

这些女人真的有谁摧毁了古代中国嘛？还是那时的男性统治者缺乏判断力、轻重不分呢？

jasonc_tutorials
history repeats itself.

历史在自行重演。

Remy N.
So were all Chinese emperors hideous, I notice the women are beautiful but the men look like super angry hairy Buddhas? Were there any good looking one?

所以，中国所有的皇帝都很丑陋吗？我注意到女人很漂亮，但是男人看起来就像是超级愤怒又长满毛的佛陀。有好看的皇帝吗？

iman cries over yoongi
I've been reading a lot of translated Chinese webnovels, and the phrase "Mountain-toppling and city-destroying beauty" was commonly used to describe a beautiful woman.

我看过很多翻译过来的中文网络小说。通常他们会用“能倾倒山体、毁掉城池的美人”（译者：倾国倾城？）来形容一个美丽的女人。

Trisna Eko Wiyatni Kawaii
helen from troy, cleopatra from egyp.. those all beautiful women that cause of war of their flawless beauty

特洛伊的海伦、埃及的克利奥帕特拉（埃及艳后）等等，所有这些美人都因为她们无暇的美貌招致了战争。

Thannia 2278
some of these women sounded like demon in disguise 

这其中有一些女人听起来就像是伪装起来的恶魔。
 
PRINCE KRAZIE
xi shi did not bring down an empire, it was a kingdom.

西施没有让一个帝国垮台，只是一个王国。

Sherry Wang
As an Asian growing up in Taiwan, I learned all these stories back in elementary school, and I really do have a problem with you making the video title as" 8 'women' who destroyed china". I understand you are trying to make the video title more appealing but the majority of the reasons why all the dynasties were eventually overturned contributing to the incompetence of the king/emperors instead of women. I think we all know that in ancient asian society, there is a strong masculine dominance and it usually pushes all the blemishes to women for all the blames. Besides, I think it would be great if you mentioned that Muo Xi (the first one) daji, and baosi are not the real historical figures (in question) because the real chinese history (中国史) started from qin (秦) dynasty; even they are, the stories you mentioned about all the women are 90% "anecdotals", instead of history. I think there is a line between history and anecdotals that needs to be cleared.

作为一个在台湾长大的亚洲人，我在小学时候就读过这些故事了。我理解视频博主想要让视频标题更具吸引力的做法，但是所有朝代最终被推翻的原因主要在于国王或者皇帝的无能，而不是那些美人。我想我们都知道，在古代的亚洲社会中，男性占据强势的主导地位，而且通常会把所有的污点都推到女人身上。我觉得如果你有提到妹喜（中国历史上第一个红颜祸水）、妲己和褒姒都不是真实的历史人物，这样会更好一些。因为真正的中国史是从秦朝开始的，而你提到的美人有90%是来自传闻轶事，而非历史。我认为历史人物和传说人物的区别还是有必要澄清一下的。

Kalo Kah
The flowers turned away in shame because of her beauty?Wth!

花儿因为她的美貌羞愧地转了头？（闭月羞花中的“羞花”）什么鬼！

Patatas Origins
The only time that I'm happy for not being beautiful XD

唯一一次我很开心自己不是一个美女。哈哈哈

Mao Mao
When the man are useless ,always women 's fault

当男人没用的时候，女人做什么都是错的。

luojihencha
Women never destroy China, they don't have any power. Women were just accessories to men in the history. It was incapable men who destroy China and blaming everything on a women is just too easy.

女人从来就没有毁灭过中国，她们没有任何权利。在中国历史上，女人只是男人的附属品。是无能的男人毁灭了中国，而且把一切都归咎在一个女人身上，这太容易了。

Stephanie Duchesne
It's always amazing to me how people find ways to blame the "beautiful" women. The men had choices, they could have made their own decisions, had their own wills, therefore this is more a  case of "it takes two to tango" than it is solely the fault of the ladies.

人们想方设法把错误归咎于“漂亮”女人，这总是让我很吃惊。男人们有选择权，他们可以自己做决定，可以有自己的意愿，所以这更像是“一个巴掌拍不响”，而不仅仅是女人们的过错。