印网友讨论：抖音在印度应该被封杀吗

Do you think TikTok (App) must be banned in India?

你觉得抖音在印度应该被封杀吗？

 Quora读者的评论：

Yatin Hiwarkar, A Simple Leisure Writer

Not sure about the app, but ‘Animal Abuse’ on Tiktok should definitely be banned.

Recently I came across few videos on Tiktok in which people are abusing their pets in the name of comedy and for likes.

Consider this first video.

Let me describe it.

This guy is lip syncing to some bollywood dialogue and manhandling his kitten just for the sake of likes.

Just look at how he is holding the kitten.

关于这个应用程序我不确定，但是抖音上“虐待动物”的风气绝对应该被封杀。

最近，我在抖音网站上看到了一些视频，视频中人们为了搞笑虐待他们的宠物，希望得到别人的点赞。

看看第一个视频。

我来解说一下。

这家伙用宝莱坞的电影对话对口型表演，为了获得点赞，粗暴地对待他的小猫。

看看他是怎么抱着小猫的。

 

He then proceeds to slap the kitten.

接着他开始扇小猫的脸。

 

Look how much the head of the kitten is displaced after this slap.

看小猫的头被扇得多狠

 

He still continues to badly manhandle the kitten.

But wait, the barbarity is not done yet. He slaps it again.

The poor kitten almost falls off his hand after this.

He is still not done yet. He grabs the neck of the kitten firmly.

他继续粗暴地对待小猫。

但是等一下，他的粗暴行径还没完。他又扇了小猫一下。

可怜的小猫差点从他的手上掉下来。

还没完，他紧紧地扼住小猫的脖子。

 

Just look at the sheer look of evil on his face, while the kitten struggles to get out of his grip.

And finally he again slaps the kitten for the third time to end the video.

看看他脸上邪恶的表情，小猫挣扎着想挣脱他的控制。

最后，他又拍了小猫第三次，结束了视频。

 

And now, see the likes he got for doing this idiotic thing.

现在，看看他因为做了这件蠢事而得到网友们多少赞。

 

2400 likes! for this inhuman act. Notice the hashtags comedy, animalcomedy.

2400个赞！对这种惨无人道的行为居然那么多人点了赞。注意看这个标签，喜剧，动物喜剧。

 

Lata Tiwari, former Life Sciences Student

Well, I think Tik Tok is like any other social media app!(Facebook, Instagrams, Snapchat)

But the questions arise that why so much problem with tiktok as compared with other apps!

1. Though in tik tok some people are really talented in terms of acting or dancing or singing,but majority of them are 'Wannabes'.They call themselves actor but they just do lipsync of any random song in front of the camera without any facial expression (which is an obvious requirement in acting).Their priorities are just to look good in front of the camera by wearing expensive branded clothes, a hell lot of makeup, and with spikes hairstyle which almost touches the ceiling!

It takes only 30s to make a video, it even does not take much time for editing and still they get soo much popularity as if they do some extraordinary work. I literally feel bad for those YouTubers who spend hell lot of time in scripting, acting, editing and still struggle for views!

If ur selling ur talent like this, it wouldn't give u much benefit in future and it will not even sustain for a long time! This popularity may also backfire those who are popular in tik tok as majority of them are teenagers, once their popularity gets down, they will surely feel bad and lose their own importance!

2.The second thing is the obscene content in tik tok!

People generally do not understand that what they should upload and what should not!! They can do anything for fame! But this problem is not limited to tiktok,u can see obscene videos or photos in insta and facebook too! But yeah tiktok is winning in this race!

At the end,All I have to say that to ban something is a big deal and it requires strong reason to do so! But we should make ourselves smart enough to figure out real talent! What does it take to get fame-the hard work, the pain, the sweat, sleepless nights, etc, etc. Don’t run after sasti sauharat!!!!

嗯，我认为抖音跟其他社交媒体应用程序没啥两样！(比如Facebook, instagram Snapchat)

但是问题来了，为什么抖音与其他应用程序相比，出了这么多问题呢！

1. 虽然抖音里有些人在表演、跳舞或唱歌方面真的很有天赋，但他们中的大多数都只是在“模仿”。他们自称是演员，但他们只会在镜头前对口型唱歌，没有任何面部表情。他们最重视的就是穿着昂贵的名牌衣服，化着浓妆，梳着几乎要顶到天花板的尖头发型，在镜头前看起来很漂亮就行！

制作一个视频只需要30秒，甚至都不需要花太多的时间来编辑，但他们还是非常受欢迎，就好像他们真的干了什么非凡的工作似的。我真的为那些花了大量时间在编剧、表演、编辑，为了浏览量苦苦挣扎的youtube用户感到难过!

如果你像这样展示才华，它不会给你的未来带来太多的好处，甚至不会持续很长时间！这种出名也可能会带来反作用，那些在抖音上受欢迎的人，因为大多数是青少年，一旦他们的热度下降，他们肯定会感到难过，觉得自己一无是处！

2.第二点就是抖音上的淫秽内容！

人们通常不清楚他们该上传什么，不该上传什么！！他们为了出名愿意做任何事情！但这个问题并不仅限于抖音，insta和facebook上也能看到淫秽视频或照片！但是抖音上最多！

最后，我要说的是，下封杀令是件大事，需要强有力的理由才能这么做！但我们应该让自己聪明点，找出真正的人才！什么能让你出名呢？——努力工作、痛苦、汗水、废寝忘食等等，等等。

 

Adarsha Lunia, Experienced ugly side of relationship

Big “Yes” ! Not only Tik tok but similar social apps. India don’t have any control over the Internet applications and how its impacting society and people around you.

1.People post anything without understand the facts Such as nationalization, racialism etc., this is serial issue in India So stop doing this. In India we have many religions and languages so if trolls something other religion will aggressive and it will start fighting and lot more things.

2.Trolling/Memo for actors , politician etc.,

3.Exposing Girls assets is another nudity in Tik tok. I saw seen many videos are exposed in porn website.

4.Admin page people , These people don’t know anything but posting non-sense with break up , love quotes , Ex’s , crying , Make up like girls and girls make up like boys they do videos , Finally they won’t get anything.

5.Social media not safe for you So big tech like Google, Facebook they are monitoring your activities So be careful about it.

Considering healthy aspects of people community we need to ban this. From this app people will not get anything but wasting time on that. Even In China people are not using much like Indian use.

绝对“该”!不仅是抖音，还有类似的社交应用都应该取缔。印度对互联网应用程序及其对社会和周围人会带来何种影响完全不加控制。

1.人们发布与民族主义、种族歧视等事实相矛盾的内容，这在印度是一个连环问题，所以不要继续这么干了。在印度，我们有很多宗教和语言，所以如果喷子攻击其他宗教，其他宗教就会发起攻击，开始争吵不休。

2.对演员、政客等进行恶搞。

3.抖音滥用女孩的资料。我看到很多视频出现在色情网站上。

4.管理员，这些人什么都不知道，只会推选一些无病呻吟的分手，爱情语录，前任，哭泣，男扮女装和女扮男装的视频。

5.社交媒体对你来说并不安全，像谷歌和Facebook这样的大科技公司正在监控你的活动，所以要小心一些。

出于对大众社区的健康的考量，我们必须封杀这个程序。人们从这个应用程序里不会得到任何东西，只会浪费时间。即使在中国，人们也不像印度人那么沉溺于手机中。

 

Priyanka K, An amateur writer on Quora

Well. Tik tok has been gaining attention among everyone. It is an app where you can showcase you creativity in acting. But is that what is happening?? Specially among the young adults this app is a must have on the phones. They are so badly addicted to it that they go to any extreme just for likes and follows. Insane..!!

This incident happened a few days ago when I was travelling in my office cab. Every person in the cab was glued to it. Even to an extent that a few people take videos in the office campus.

If used in a proper way it is still a good entertainment. But people misuse the whole purpose of it. Young girls tend to expose themselves and enact on some filthy music and song just for likes. We have very well heard of suicide cases because of the misuse of tik tok. There is even a case of a mother killing her 2 small kids to elope with her new found love on tik tok.

Atleast if not banned this should be made to use in the proper way. I honestly do not see a purpose of this app.

嗯，抖音已经引起了大家的注意。这是一个应用程序，你可以通过表演展示你的创造力。但事实就是这样吗?特别是对于年轻人来说，这款应用是手机上的必备程序。他们如此沉迷于这个程序，以至于他们为了点赞数和关注量而不遗余力。太疯狂了! !

这件事发生在几天前，当时我正坐在公司的通勤车上。车里的每个人都沉溺于这个程序中。甚至有些人还在办公室里拍视频。

如果使用得当，它是一种很好的娱乐方式。但是人们滥用了它。年轻的女孩为了博点赞，暴露身体，表演一些下流的音乐和歌曲。我们还听说过有人因为抖音而自杀。甚至有这样一个例子，一个母亲为了跟在抖音上结识的新欢私奔，狠心杀害了她的两个孩子。

如果没有被封杀，至少也应该以正确的方式使用。老实说，我看不出这个应用程序有什么用途。

 

Nisha Gupta, studied at Reva University,Bangalore

Tik tok is actually an app which makes no sense and the Indian youths think that this is a way to earn money and get popularity. I see many people act very stupid, desperate in the videos. Their intention might be to make people laugh but wrong they just end up looking very stupid. They call themselves tiktok actor. Like seriously actor for what just to move your lips.

Yes, it should be banned not only in India but everywhere. An app which is useless encourage ppl to prove how stupid they are. If you want to become popular or earn money hardwork is needed. For how long an app can't give you money.

抖音实际上是一款毫无意义的应用，印度年轻人把它当成一种赚钱和出名的途径。我看到很多人在视频中表现得非常愚蠢。他们可能是想逗人们笑，但他们把自己搞得非常愚蠢。他们自称抖音演员。

是的，它不仅应该在印度被封杀，而且在世界各地都该被封杀。一个无用的应用程序只会让人们证明他们有多么愚蠢。如果你想出名或赚钱，就必须努力工作。应用程序给不了你钱的。

 

More Like Me

No absolutely no.I am not a tik tok user nor a fan of the app.but that doesn't mean it can be banned. It is banned due to pornographic content. I am not able to find anything (that doesn't mean there is not)but it problem with how they censor videos. If you look youtube pornography and nudity is blocked there and promoted. Their algorithm picks these up and delete them. I think the censoring and moderating videos is the solution. I read that they have moderating team. So you can report the videos. And they have many features to censor comments,i know they are not foolproof but the community and the users can help them to maintain it.

Banning make absolutely no sense .i think it is against freedom of speech.

不，绝对不应该。我不是抖音的用户，也不是抖音的粉丝，但这并不意味着它就该被封杀止。抖音因为黄色内容被封杀。我找不到任何这种东西(当然这并不意味着没有)，但问题是他们是如何审查视频的。我认为对视频进行审查是一个解决办法。所以你可以报告视频。他们会审查评论，我知道他们不是万无一失的，但社区和用户可以帮助他们维护程序。

封杀抖音程序是完全没有道理的，我认为这违反了言论自由

 

Surabhi Raghuwanshi, Btech from Lakshmi Narain College of Technology, Bhopal (2021)

Well!!!…NO….

According to me ,there is no harm in it. It is a new way of represting oneself in the form of expressions and actions and enjoying the life. Now everyone has the chance to show their own dramatic styles and no need to copy others .Many people get popularised by this ..and make their impact in coming web series with lead role. Such eg is Munjal Khattar,Marunal Punchal,Garima Chaurasia and many more..Its time to try yourself too in it. If u wish so.

嗯! ! !不应该……..

在我看来，抖音没有什么害处。它是一种新的表达自我，享受生活的途径。现在每个人都有机会展示自己的风格，不需要模仿别人。如果你愿意的话，是时候进行自我尝试了。

 

Abhimanyu Aryan, Founder at IV Dimension Studios

Yes. Also, we should ban all Chinese apps. Not give China any kind of data. We have to rely on China for hardware for a couple of years like(Apple etc). Samsung moved production to India.

But for apps yes, we should ban all of them because there are too many alternatives already like Samosa etc. If they don’t make headquarters in India then Indians don’t get paid in any way possible. Facebook, Microsoft, Amazon, OnePlus all have offices in India so Indian people get employment. So for these companies, it makes sense

I'm extremely happy that TikTok is banned in India. It's so stupid of us that we Indian are letting China AI get better at recognising patterns in content generated by Indian people. So first they are generating huge revenue with our data, over that we helping them achieve state of the art results in recognising spatial features. Wow plz don't lift the ban

是的。此外，我们应该封杀所有的中国应用程序。不要给中国任何数据。几年来，我们不得不依赖中国的硬件，比如(苹果等)。三星将生产转移到了印度。

但是对于应用程序来说，是的，我们应该封杀所有的应用程序，因为我们有太多的替代品了，比如Samosa等等。如果他们不把总部设在印度，印度人就得不到任何可能的报酬。Facebook、微软(Microsoft)、亚马逊(Amazon)和一加(OnePlus)都在印度设有办事处，这样印度人就有了工作。所以对这些公司来说，这么做是有道理的。

我非常高兴抖音在印度被封杀。首先，他们通过我们的数据创造了巨大的收入，我们帮助他们在识别空间特征方面取得了最先进的成果。请不要解除封杀令。

 

Sindhu Murugesan, UI Developer at Netmeds Pharmacy (2017-present)

My brother is not available whenever a conversation happens in my home or whenever I need him for some help. Because he will be isolated and do some crazy activities in front of his mobile. He doesn't concentrate on his studies. This doesn't stop at my home.

When I see news, there are bunch of youths who meet with everyday accidents when they try to do tik tok while they driving.

Some of the students make fun of their class teachers without their knowledge. They fail to know the value of a human moral.

This is an time and life eating app. It should be banned orelse those people will suffer when they put thier phone down and face thier real life.

每当我们在家中聊天或我需要他帮忙的时候，我哥哥都不像隐形人一样不存在。因为他会自己呆在角落，抱着手机做一些疯狂的事。他没法专心学习。这种现象不单单发生在我家。

我看过新闻，有一群年轻人，试图一边开车一边拍抖音，最后发生了事故。

一些学生嘲笑他们的班主任。他们根本没有人类该有的道德价值。

这是一个消耗时间和生命的应用程序。它应该被封杀，因为当这些人放下手机，面对现实生活时，他们会感到痛苦。

 

Tuba Khan, former Student

Before moving forward, let us understand what this app is all about.

TikTok is an iOS and Android media app used for creating and sharing short videos. It's owned by bytedance. On September 2016 it was first introduced in China as “Douyin”and introduced to overseas market as TikTok one year later.

According to me, it would be unfair to ban TikTok. Because, the move will handicap the app's owner, China's Bytedance Ltd. , which is currently world's most valued startup, in one of it's most promising market. More than 100 millions of Indian's download the app, and between 30–40 millions are actively using it. The ban is curlating freedom of expression, as it empowers users to express themselves, via video, lip-syncing and acting. It enable people to showcase their talent.

I don't turn the blind eye towards the offensive content circulated on TikTok. Their is a higher chances to get exploited and get offended in a platform like this. And, this has actually happened: A 24 year old boy V Kalaiyarasan, a resident of kannikapuram in Vyasarpadi , a northern suburb in Chennai, has killed himself after he was bullied and insulted on TikTok. And, many offensive incident has happened earlier too. But such bullying can happen anywhere even on Facebook, Twitter or Instagram. That doesn't mean that we should stop using them instead of that appropriate measures should be taken to make them safe and secured for the users. The internet has tone and tone of ideas on how to commit suicide, how to kill a person, how to make bomb, how to harrss someone without living a fragment of trace.

Does that mean internet should be banned too?

If not, why to single out TikTok?

According to section 79 of Information and Technology Act in India provides protection to online mediums and platforms from lawsuits and defaming.

For instance:- Facebook or WhatsApp owner cannot be held accountable for anything that has been posted on their platform. Hence, by this banning TikTok in India due to the content shared on their platform is completely illogical and illegal.

Instead of bannig an appropriate rules and regulations should be taken. For instance:- As this happen with TikTok in US, TikTok created separate app for kids, and infused additional saftey measures and protocols to ensure that no harrsement and abused to be carried on the platform. After TikTok met the regulations imposed by US Federal trade commission and everything is fine there now. Content has been segregated based on audience profile, and more filters and checks has been imposed. Parents have been educated on how to monitor the content accessed by their children.

Hence TikTok shouldn't be banned.

在继续分析之前，让我们先来了解一下这个应用程序是什么。

抖音是一个iOS和Android媒体应用程序，用于创建和分享短视频。它归今日头条所有。2016年9月，“抖音”首次在中国推出，一年后又以TikTok的名字推向海外市场。

在我看来，封杀抖音是不公正的行为。因为，此举将阻碍这款应用的所有者中国今日头条在最有前景的市场之一的发展。今日头条目前是全球市值最高的初创公司。超过1亿印度人下载了这款应用，其中有3000万至4000万人是活跃用户。这项封杀令限制了言论自由，因为它赋予用户通过视频、假唱和表演来表达自己的权利。它让人们能够有地方展示他们的才华。

我不会对抖音上流传的攻击性内容视而不见。事实上，这已经发生了：一名24岁的男孩维卡拉亚拉萨在抖音遭到欺凌和侮辱后自杀身亡。而且，之前也发生过许多恶性事件。但这种霸凌可能发生在任何地方，Facebook、Twitter或Instagram上也难免发生。这并不意味着我们应该封杀它们，而是应该采取适当的措施来确保它们对用户的安全。关于如何自杀，如何杀人，如何制造炸弹，如何在没有一丝痕迹的情况下骚扰他人，互联网上充斥着各种各样的观点。

这是否意味着互联网也应该被封杀？

如果答案是否定的，为什么要对抖音区别对待呢？

根据印度《信息与技术法》第79条，印度为网络媒体和平台提供保护，使其免受诉讼和诽谤。

例如：Facebook或WhatsApp的用户无需对他们平台上发布的任何内容负责。因此，因为抖音平台上共享的内容而在印度封杀抖音，是完全不合逻辑和非法的。

应该采取适当的规章制度，而非直接下封杀令。例如：正如抖音在美国所做的那样，为孩子们创建了单独的应用程序，加载了安全措施和协议条款，以确保平台上不存在任何不良内容。抖音满足了美国联邦贸易委员会的要求，一切都很顺利。平台内容已根据用户配置文件进行了隔离，并实施了更多的筛选和检查。父母也接受了如何监控孩子访问内容的教育。

因此，抖音不应该被封杀。