quora: 中国有印度布拉莫斯那么先进的导弹吗？

Does China have a cruise missile that's as advanced as the BrahMos of India?

中国有印度布拉莫斯那么先进的导弹吗？

quora读者的评论：

Mo Nong Shu Xiang

No,absolutelly not

没有，绝对没有

 

Mark Guan

Don’t know for sure, but I think YJ-12(鹰击12) is about the same level as BrahMos

不确定，鹰击12导弹应该是和布拉莫斯一样先进

 

Enming Yang, Studied military equipment for 5 years

Yes, depending on use, we have an entire family of them， one of them is the CJ-10 or DF-10, which have a tripled range, a doubled warhead

有啊，我们有一整个家族系列的导弹，有CJ-10 和 DF-10，射程是3倍，双弹头

 

Andrew Roberts

Which China, as the Republic has the Hsiung Feng III, while the People's variant has a few, eg. YJ-12, YJ-18, YJ-91, …

哪个中国啊，台湾那边有雄风III

大陆那边有 YJ-12, YJ-18, YJ-91, …

 

Shang Qi, studied at China University of Geosciences
Updated Nov 17, 2017

No, India’s cruise missile is the most advanced missile in the world !!!

But do you believe it?

没有。印度巡航导弹是世界最先进的！

你们信吗。

Abhishek Raj, studied at DAV Public School

Brahmos

It is a supersonic stealth cruise missile, jointly developed by India and Russia.

布拉莫斯导弹是超音速隐形巡航导弹，由印度和俄罗斯联合研发

Range - 300KM

Speed - upto 3 Mach

Can carry upto 300 Kgs of conventional warhead and can be operated from land, sea, and air.

射程300公里，速度高达3马赫，可以携带300公斤的常规弹头，可以从陆地发射，也可以从海上和空中发射。

Its chinese counterparts are -

GB-6A

中国的同款导弹是GB-6A

It is subsonic stealth cruise missile, (copied from)American JSOW-ER.

Range - upto 600 Km

Speed - less than 1 Mach(0.65 Mach)

Can carry upto 500 Kgs of warhead and can be operated from air only.

GB-6A是一款亚音速隐形巡航导弹，抄袭了美国的JSOW-ER

射程600公里，速度不到1马赫（只有0.65马赫）

能携带500公斤常规弹头，只能从空中发射

2. CM-302 aka Swift Death

It is a supersonic antiship cruise missile.

Range - Upto 300 Km

Speed - Upto 4 Mach

Can carry upto 250 Kgs of warhead and can be operated from sea only.

CM-302是超音速反舰巡航导弹

射程300公里，速度4马赫

能携带250公斤的弹头，只能从海上发射

3. WS- 43

The WS-43 is tactical cruise missile that can even hunt for its own targets once launched and programmed to patrol an area for up to 30 minutes.

WS- 43是一款战术导弹，发射后自动追踪目标。

Range - 60 Km

Speed - classified

Can carry upto 20 Kgs of warhead, with 30 mins loitering time.

射程60公里，能携带20公斤弹头

 来源：三泰虎 http://www.santaihu.com/45922.html

Bob Keeter, Retired flight test / systems engineer / engineering lead

The Chinese PLAN operates at least four Sovremennyy-class destroyers that carry the Moskit (NATO: “Sunburn”) anti-ship missikes. While different from the Brahmos missile, these are at least in the same class.

中国海军至少服役了4款现代级驱逐舰，装备有Moskit反舰导弹。

虽然不同于布拉莫斯弹道，不过至少是同一等级的导弹。

Moskit

Weight is 9900 lbs at launch with a 710 lb conventional armor piercing or 120 KT nuclear warhead. The missile has a range of around 150 miles at an altitude of 60 ft above sea level and a speed of Mach 3.

Moskit导弹重9900磅，能携带710磅的常规弹头，或者核弹头，射程150英里，速度3马赫。

Brahmos

Weight is about 6600 lbs with a 440 lb conventional or nuclear warhead. The missile has a range of up to 280 miles with possible extension from ongoing development. Speed is also up to Mach 3. Apparently the major new feature if this missile is the ability to fly out to the target area at high altitude conserving fuel and extending range, then to dive to a very low altitude 10–15 feet over the water for final attack.

This extremely low attack altitude decreases the initial possible detectionrange by any given sensor (ie at the radar horizon) by approximately 5 miles. Inbound at M3, every second of earlier detection is critical for ship defenses.

布拉莫斯导弹重大约6600磅，能携带440磅的常规弹头或核弹头。

射程为280英里，速度高达3马赫。

显然，布拉莫斯导弹的主要新功能是可以高空巡航奔向目标，并在快到达目的后降至10-15英尺的高度飞向目标。

如此低空飞行，避免被雷达提前侦测到。对军舰来说，每早一秒发现来袭导弹都是至关重要的。