网友讨论：中国公路比印度公路更好吗

Are the Chinese roads better than India, and do the Chinese use concrete roads for powerful structures?

中国公路比印度公路更好吗，中国修公路是浇筑混泥土吗

quora读者的评论：

Rehan Baji, BE Civil Engineering & Bachelor of Engineering Degrees, University of Mumbai (2007)

My dear , There is nothing like powerful term in Concrete.

It simply depends upon the grade of the Concrete.

Higher the Grade of the Concrete , Higher will be it's Load carrying capacity.

公路路况如何，那就看混泥土的等级

浇筑的混泥土等级越高，公路质量就越好，承载重量就越大

Still , If We want to cast a Concrete Road , above the Ground Level , The Maximum Grade of Concrete which we use is M40 to the best of my knowledge, which is almost same in both India and China.

But what makes thier roads much better than us is the durability of the Concrete used there which is far better as compared to us.

This I have to accept , simply because the Durability of the Concrete relies mainly on Quality Control and Good Workmanship.

Regarding Good Workmanship, we are as same as them.

But , then regarding Quality Control, As an Indian , I feel sad , we still have to improve on it.

And that's why thier Roads are better than us and are fit for use all the 12 months of the Year.

中国公路质量更好，归功于使用的混泥土质量比我们的好得多。

混泥土的质量，主要取决于质量管控和工艺水平。

作为印度人，我觉得我们的质量管控还需要改进。

所以，中国公路比我们的公路更好，一年四季都对外开放。

 

Yu Xu, lives in Toronto, ON

You must be living in the 1970s …or brainwashed by western media.

你不是生活在1970年代，就是被西方媒体洗脑了

China and India both are large country with large population. They both face great economic problem. Their situation is pretty much the same.

中国和印度都是大国，都有着众多人口。两国都面临着经济问题，处境是大体一样的

Normal roads in Beijing:

以下是北京的普通公路

Not-So-Good roads in Beijing:

北京不怎么样的公路

Not-So-Good Provincial Roads:

省道

Poor Road:

路况差的公路

Most roads in China are concrete, unless it is not effective (nomadic plain) or too small (sideways in villages).

中国公路大多数是混泥土铺设的。

 

Samson Min, diesel Engine Engineer

YES，Actually，better than USA

没错，中国公路不仅比印度公路好，还比美国公路更好

 

Quora User, knows Chinese

I haven't been to India but from the internet and some media reports I think that China’s infrastructure construction is much better than the India’s.

Many newly built roads and highways in China are excellent, especially bridge construction .

我没去过印度。不过，从网上获取的信息以及媒体的报道来看，我觉得中国基础设施比印度基础设施好太多了。

中国新建的公路非常赞，特别是架设的桥梁更是令人叹为观止

Some pics

The Longshan Bridge in Guizhou province

贵州龙山大桥

The East Sea Bridge from Shanghai to Yangshan

上海通往阳山的东海大桥

The Jiaozhou Bay Bridge in Shandong province

山东胶州湾大桥

The Hangzhou Bay Bridge in Zhejiang province

浙江杭州湾跨海大桥

As for the second question, I know roads in China mostly are build in asphalt while some old roads maybe were built in concrete. But I donot know the deatails as my major is politics not engineering.

中国公路主要是泊油路，以前修的一些公路是混泥土浇筑的。