印度网友热议：印官员称最早发现万有引力的是一名印度人

JAIPUR: A Rajasthan minister known for his controversial remarks has now claimed that Indian mathematician and astronomer Brahmagupta-II (598-670) discovered the law of gravity over 1,000 years before Issac Newton (1642-1727) did.
Speaking at the 72nd foundation day ceremony of Rajasthan University on Monday, state education minister Vasudev Devnani wondered why the "fact" was not included in the academic curriculum.

"Since childhood, we have been reading that Newton discovered the law of gravity, but in reality, an Indian astronomer discovered it, if you revisit history," said Devani.

Amid criticism, the minister asked his detractors on Tuesday to read texts and books by Brahmagupta before passing any judgement on his statement. "An impression is being made that I have made a fictional statement. I would not comment on my statement. Rather, I would ask those who have expressed disbelief and shock to at least read the texts of Brahmagupta or read the research carried out on him by modern scientists," he added.

印度一位地方教育官员打算挑战历史。该官员称，最早发现万有引力的并不是牛顿，而是一名印度数学家，而且这位印度科学家发现万有引力的时间要比牛顿早一千多年。

向来发表有争议性言论而著称的拉贾斯坦邦教育部长瓦苏德夫•德夫纳尼声称，印度数学家和天文学家婆罗摩笈多二世（Brahmagupta-II，598-670）首先发现了万有引力定律，这比牛顿（1642-1727）发现的时间早了一千多年。

1月8日，在拉贾斯坦邦大学举行的第72届奠基仪式上，瓦苏德夫•德夫纳尼发问，为何该“事实”没有纳入学术大纲中？他说：“自上小学以来，我们的教材上写的都是牛顿发现了万有引力定律，但实际上，如果你重温历史，你会发现它是一位印度天文学家首先发现的。”

印度时报网友评论：

来源：三泰虎 http://www.santaihu.com/44083.html

Tushar Sharma
3473
Tushar Sharma - 1 day ago

This is true. Puspak Viman before write brothers. even bicycle in south indian temples .. Bramhastra is an ancient form of Nuclear bomb ..

没错， Puspak Viman比莱特兄弟早（发明飞机）..

古代的Bramhastra，其实就是原子弹的一种

 

Muhammad The Butcher
15546
Muhammad The Butcher - Humanity's Worst Enemey - 1 day ago

Knowledge always existed. Scientists only gave explanations to this already existing knowledge but did not discover already existed knowledge.

知识本来就存在

科学家只是对已经存在的知识给出解释而已，并不算发现。

 

Hemanath C
7022
Hemanath C - 1 day ago

That’s a fact. But sickulars won’t buy it.

这是事实

不过有些人是不会买账的

idu
2765
didu - 1 day ago

INDIA has rich heritage of knowledge that was looted by foreigners and made patents from looted knowledge. We all should be proud and work hard to become self dependent and innovative again.

印度有着丰富的知识遗产，这些知识被外国人学走后进而捣鼓出他们自己的发明。

骄傲吧，让我们再次创新，让我们再次独立自主

 

Venkat Pokkunuri
9265
Venkat Pokkunuri - Location - 1 day ago

I dont find any thing wrog in his statement; it looks, as if it is correct, except for the fact that, the force of attraction was not naed as Gravitational Force

我不觉得他说的有啥错

看起来没错啊，无非就是没有说是“万有引力”而已

 

Vinod.raj42
Vinod.raj42 - 1 day ago

Rajastan is a state which creates Jokers...

拉贾斯坦邦到处是小丑啊

 

Francis VA
424
Francis - 1 day ago

Rajasthan has got an uneducated education minister.

拉贾斯坦邦有了一位没文化的教育部长啊

 

gaurav jain
1437
gaurav jain - Location - 1 day ago

We are a 5000 yr old civilization. We had mohenjodaro. Which was a scientific built city.bramaashtra or atom BOM has mentions in our holy texts

我们印度有着5000年的古老文明历史

我们有摩亨佐达罗城这么一座用科技打造的城市。

我们的圣书早就提到了原子弹

 

vijay goswami
566
Vijay - 1 day ago

It's just bcz of Islamic invaders, all the works were burnt to ashes. And later we were turned secular.

都怪伊斯兰入侵者，一切作品都被烧为灰烬。

 

Reggie D##apos##souza
4826
Reggiedsouza - Location - 1 day ago

this is the same moron who last year said cows exhale oxygen . this chutya is as dumb as capt ajit. ignore him as he can't digest being a low life.

去年就是这个笨蛋说牛呼出的是氧气的

无视他即可

 

Karthik Kart
745
Karthik Kart - Mumbai, India - 1 day ago

The oNly thing we invented was how to produce babies

我们唯一发明的是如何生孩子

 

Timothy Chang
294
Timothy Chang - 1 day ago

Without reading the whole news i am pretty sure which party this minister would belong to!

不用看文章，我就知道这位部长来自哪个政党！

 

Appa Durai
16903
Appa Durai - 1 day ago

Science is making reality known to public.People knew that objects fall on earth from the space.Newton explained it

科学就是让民众了解真相

大家都知道东西是从上往下掉的，而牛顿对这一现象进行了科学解释

 

GoelS
11800
GoelS - New Delhi - 1 day ago

This guy actually does not know who newton was!

其实这个家伙连牛顿是谁都不知道

 

gksurya_99
3969
gksurya_99 - 1 day ago

This is the problem with India. Indians do not respect Indians, but prefer to praise white skinned fellows. Indians get more respect outside India than within India. This is why Indians do better outside India.

这就是印度的问题所在

印度人不尊重自己人，喜欢夸白人

印度人在国外获得的尊重超过在国内享受的尊重

这就是印度人喜欢去国外的原因

 

Muhammad The Butcher
15552
Muhammad The Butcher - Humanity's Worst Enemey - 1 day ago

Newton only explained the concept of Gravity. Gravity existed all the time.

牛顿只是解释了万有引力这个概念，其实引力一直是存在的

 

Swami Babananda
4505
Swami Babananda - 1 day ago

If this is true why did India turn into third world shitthole. Why did Newtons small country f#$k us for 3 centuries.

如果是真的话，为什么印度沦为了第三世界屎坑

为什么牛顿所在的小小国家强奸了印度长达3个世纪之久。

 

Vinod.raj42
Vinod.raj42 - 1 day ago

Rajstan is a state which created different kind of Jokers & idiots...this guy is among one......

拉贾斯坦邦是一个培养各种小丑和笨蛋的邦。这个家伙就是其中之一

 

Aryan Rajput
249
Aryan Rajput - 1 day ago

He is correct
Read the original authentic indian history if one can find & notbthe leftist macaulian history.

他说得是对的

去翻阅印度古代历史就知道了

 

Laxmanan Swamidoss Mohandoss
2631
Laxmanan Swamidoss Mohandoss - USA - 1 day ago

Hello!minister,why did not say it to the world before Newton?

你好，部长，为什么不赶在牛顿之前向世界宣布呢

 

Anik Chowdhury
2629
Anik - Kolkata - 1 day ago

We need a detailed analysis by historians over this and the result to be given to the world scientists who knows maybe history will be rewritten

我们需要一位历史学家出来就此给出详细的分析。

也许历史会重写

 

shiv
shiv - rajkot - 1 day ago

After altering Indian history, they are attemting to change world history.

在篡改了印度历史后，他居然想改变世界历史

 

gowtha man
696
Gowtha - 1 day ago

Idiot

笨蛋

 

Tanveer Shaikh
382
Tanveer - 1 day ago

BJP invented the word and definition of "Nationalism" ...

印度人民党发明了“民族主义”这个词，并诠释了这个词的定义

 

Dangalla Dinamani
11957
Dangalla Dinamani - Sun - 1 day ago

Lol......And Aryabhatta-II discovered Theory of Relativity...!!

哈哈，Aryabhatta-II发现了相对论

 

Shriganesh
11022
Shriganesh - Mumbai - 1 day ago

How many Indians have read ancient books of India? Very little. Many have not seen a book of Vedas, upanishadas.

有多少印度人看过印度古书籍？

很少！

很少人看过吠陀经

 

Abhijeet
Abhijeet - Mumbai - 1 day ago

Actually what will be invented or discovered in the future has already been discovered by Indians of the past. So please don''t challenge us.

其实，以后的发明或者发现，其实印度人在过去都已经发现了。

请别来挑战我们印度啊

 

A concerned concerned
8085
A Concerned Concerned - 1 day ago

Minister is right. Not just gravity, even calculus attributed to Newton was invented in India a lot earlier

部长说得是对的

不仅是万有引力，就连微积分学也很早就在印度创立了

 

Jai Viraat Singh
695
Jai - Mumbai - 1 day ago

Whats wrong in what he said ? Brahmgupta indeed mentioned gravity in his works in the 7th century.

他哪里说错了？

Brahmgupta早在7世纪就在自己的书中提到了万有引力

 

Sujeevaraju Kaki
274
Sujeevaraju - 1 day ago

joker.

小丑

 

Natarajan D
11127
Natarajan D - TN - 1 day ago

Very good to bring out this fact. Let India go to UN to replace the name of Newton.

很好，他道出了真相。

印度赶紧去联合国把牛顿的名字换掉

 

Lucky B
4252
Lucky B - 1 day ago

Europeans did not have any knowledge about science till 14th century. Once they start colonizing Asia, they got scientific knowledge. India pioneered binary system, decimal system, Algebra (Beej-Gadit), Plastic Surgery( Sushurut), Aurvedic science, Yoga etc. Palmistry, Numerology etc were learnt from Indians

14世纪之前，欧洲人一点知识都没有

殖民亚洲后，欧洲人学到了科学知识。

二进制，十进制，代数，整形外科，瑜伽，手相术,数字命理学等，统统都是从印度人这里学到的

 

Hemant Gupta
5031
Hemant - 1 day ago

Ancient India has all the knowledge of science and technology. However European may have discovered it late and patented the discovery as one of them and theirs.

古印度已经掌握了所有科学知识。

后来，欧洲人学到后就去申请专利，结果变成他们的发明了