印度新教育政策的语言列表中，“中文”被除名，印网民热议

 ‘Chinese’, in NEP’s 2019 languages list, dropped

印度新教育政策的语言列表中，“中文”被除名

BENGALURU: The National Education Policy (NEP) approved by the Union cabinet two days ago does not mention ‘Chinese’ among the foreign languages it cites as examples students can learn at the secondary level.

班加罗尔：联邦内阁两天前通过的《国家教育政策》(NEP)中并没有提到“汉语”可作为学生在中学阶段学习的外语。

The ‘Chinese’ language (rather than Mandarin or Cantonese) was mentioned in the draft released in 2019. It had named French, German, Spanish, Chinese and Japanese as foreign languages which could be offered as electives, and not in place of the three-language formula.

2019年公布的草案中曾提及“汉语”(不是普通话或广东话)，与法语、德语、西班牙语、汉语和日语列为选修课外语，但并不在三种必修语言之列。

The approved policy released by the Centre on Wednesday omits Chinese.

周三发布的这项已批准的政策删除了汉语。

‘Chinese out of NEP, reason is obvious’

“汉语出局，原因是显而易见的”

The ones cited are Korean, Japanese, Thai, French, German, Spanish, Portuguese and Russian “for students to learn about the cultures of the world and enrich their global knowledge and mobility according to their own interests and aspirations”.

“为了让学生了解世界文化，根据自己的兴趣和志向丰富他们的全球知识，在列的语言有韩语、日语、泰国语、法语、德语、西班牙语、葡萄牙语和俄语。

An official associated with the formulation of the final NEP said he was unaware of the change, but “the reasons are obvious”. India has banned over 100 Chinese apps following a face-off with China in eastern Ladakh. Foreign-language teachers say Chinese as a language was gaining popularity in Bengaluru since 2017, and was set to surpass many Asian languages, including Japanese.

一位参与制定《新教育政策》的官员表示，他没注意到这一变化，但“原因很明显”。在与中国在拉达克东部发生对峙后，印度禁用了100多款中国APP。外语教师表示，自2017年以来，汉语作为一门语言在班加罗尔越来越受欢迎，并将超过包括日语在内的许多亚洲语言。

However, no one signed up for the March 2020 programme for the Chinese language.

然而，没有人报名参加2020年3月的汉语课程。

 

以下是印度时报读者的评论：

Ashok Prabhu

we need to learn chinese to understand our enemy better and we will be in a better position to destroy them

知己知彼百战百胜，我们需要学习汉语，这样能更好地了解我们的敌人，更容易击败他们。

 

Vamsi Jonnalagadda

Realizing this, Britishers destroyed our ancient language Sanskrit to weaken us culturally.

英国人摧毁了我们的古语梵语，削弱了我们的文化。

 

Vinod Kumar

Good riddance. Just root out everything that is Chinese.

太好了，铲除一切和中国有关的东西。

 

Manu M

One should know enemies language to keep a step ahead.Should not be blindly making the decision. The more you know your enemy the better position you are to deal with.

要领先一步，就必须了解敌人的语言。不应该盲目地做决定，越了解你的敌人，就越容易对付他们。

Vanza Chandrag

You do not need language to understand Chinese Snake.

不需要了解他们的语言也知道他们不是好人。

 

Vanza Chandrag

China and Pakistan will forever be enemies of India, China has no friends.

中国和巴基斯坦永远是印度的敌人，中国没有朋友。

 

Saibal Mazumdar

correct measure undertaken....its time for the Chinese to know that they r not welcome here .

做得对…这下中国人该知道他们在这里不受欢迎了。

 

HSF

Mandarin is compulsory in Pakistan, so, leave Indians, if, we don't want to learn Chinese.

在巴基斯坦，汉语是必修课，但印度人不想学汉语。

 

Independent Observer

This is too childish and a clear lack of farsightedness. We need more people who are proficient in Chinese and her culture for building relationship and if needed for spying as well!

这太幼稚了，显然缺乏远见。我们需要更多精通中文和中国文化的人来和他们建立关系，如果需要的话也可以派他们去做间谍!

 

Shrikrishna Padhye

This is not an intelligent move. Not buying or importing anything Chinese is one thing but not learning Chinese is another.

这不是明智之举。可以不进口中国货，不买中国货，但学汉语和这是两码事。

 

vela koran

China's population is 1.4 billion China consumes almost 50% of the world's resources. Learning their language is and always will be an advantage.

中国有14亿人口，消耗了世界近50%的资源。学习他们的语言，无论是现在还是将来都能成为一种优势。

 

A Dutt

We are caught in a vicious cycle of stupidity.

我们陷入了愚蠢的恶性循环。

 

Shamsher

one should know his adversary inside out and the best way to know about him is through his language. it is short sighted to drop Chinese from courses offered.

应该深入了解对手，而了解对手的最好方式就是通过其语言。取消汉语真是鼠目寸光。

 

Kushu Sharma

like they say, we must learn from the adversary in order to tackle them. language is a must

就像他们说的，知己知彼百战百胜。学习对手的语言是必须的

 

Gopal T

We should learn Chinese to understand what the enemy is up to... get it back please ...

我们应该学习中文，了解敌人在做什么……把汉语加进去吧……

 

Manu R

Mandarin/Cantonese should be included.

Learning a language or using their food recipe does not mean it's anti-national.

We will have a huge advance over them if we understand their motives and languages.

They say, ""Keep your friends close, but your enemies closer"

普通话/广东话应包括在内。学习他们的语言或烹饪配方并不意味着这是反国家的。如果我们了解他们的语言和动机，就能先发制人。中国人说:“亲近你的朋友，但更要亲近你的敌人。”

 

Nag Balkur

Chinese or Mandarin should be an option as one needs to study it to fully understand what the chinese are up to

应该纳入汉语或普通话，需要学习中国人的语言才能了解他们在做什么

 

Deepak

This is a foolish step! We need to learn every language and specially Chinese because in a war when we need to interpret their communications, it will be next to impossible if we don't know Chinese language!. This is a strategic blunder being commited.

愚蠢啊！我们需要学习每一种语言，特别是汉语。在战争中，我们需要破译他们的通讯，如果我们不懂汉语，这几乎是不可能的！我们正在犯一个战略错误。

 

Sebastian Prakash

Chinese Language should be taught in every school of India to manage our Chinese enemies and to be successful in the International arena. Our educational policies has to be designed intelligently looking towards the future dynamics of the world.

为了对付中国敌人，并在国际舞台上取得成功，印度的每一所学校都应该教授汉语。我们在制定教育政策时要明智一点，必须着眼于世界未来的动态。

 

Manoj Mishra

knowing Chinese is militarily, strategically and culturally also very important .we need to understand their inner strategies as much as possible .and we should also launch a propaganda attack against the communist party of China through online medium that may intrude deep into the Chinese inner lands .

从军事上、战略上和文化上了解中国人，这是非常重要的，我们需要尽可能了解他们的内部战略，我们也应该通过网络媒介对中国发动一次宣传攻势，这样才能深入到中国内陆地区。

 

Akshay Sawant

Im struggling to understand the logic behind this emotional patriotism. We are boycotting Chinese products, services & now languages due to what is happening in Ladakh. Fair enough! But how come we are accepting Chinese funding for the IPL under VIVO sponsorship!!! More than patriotism, it looks more of Hypocritism!

很难理解这种爱国主义情绪背后的逻辑。由于拉达克事件，我们抵制中国产品、服务和语言，这很好!

但是为什么我们愿意接受中国VIVO赞助印度板球超级联赛呢!

伪君子!

 

Sudarshan Nityananda

Short sighted. We need to learn an adversary's language , though it need not be mandatory.

目光短浅。我们需要学习对手的语言，但不需要作为必修语言。

 

K Mohan Twincities

Other countries should also follow our foot steps

其他国家也应该跟随我们的脚步

 

Indi frogs

Who cares? Indians can learn Hindi, which most Indian minorities reject and nobody in the world cares about it. Be a frog trapped in an deep well.

谁在乎呢?印度人可以学习印地语，但大多数印度少数民族排斥印地语，而且其他国家的人都不在乎印地语，我们就像一只坐在深井里的青蛙。